We bought the subaru bars when we picked up our Ascent and we picked up a Yakima Skybox 16. We did a dry run last weekend with it on the highway (empty) and didn't have any wind noise. Road trip from SD to MN in a couple of weeks so we are pretty excited to get luggage in it and out of the vehicle. Install takes about 10 minutes if you have your rack preset up. I don't think you can make a bad choice between the two products but I don't know much about the Thule's.